Back to Politics briefing
Front of the U.S. Supreme Court Building in Washington, with its marble columns, steps and seated statues under a partly cloudy sky
Politics

Supreme Court agrees to rule on Trump's border asylum ban

The Supreme Court said Friday it will decide whether President Trump can shut off asylum at the U.S.-Mexico border under his Day 1 "invasion" proclamation, which two lower courts found unlawful. The ban stays in effect while the case is pending, and a ruling is expected by late June or early July.

By US Brief desk · Updated 2026-11-14T04:10:00-08:00

AI-assisted · US Brief desk · Sources listed below

What happened

The Supreme Court agreed Friday to decide whether President Trump can bar migrants who cross the southern border from seeking asylum. The justices took up the administration's appeal in Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, according to the court's order list. Markwayne Mullin, the named petitioner, is the Homeland Security secretary.

Why it matters

The ban remains in force because the D.C. Circuit put its own ruling on hold during the appeal, CBS and SCOTUSblog reported. NBC said the ruling will be the final word on how far a president can go in shutting off asylum claims that Congress wrote into law. It is the third significant Trump immigration case the court is weighing, alongside cases on deportations to third countries and detention without bond hearings, NBC reported.

More context

The policy: On Jan. 20, 2025, his first day back in office, Trump declared that "an invasion is ongoing at the southern border." He suspended entry for migrants crossing between ports of entry or without papers and barred them from asylum and related protections, SCOTUSblog and CBS News reported. Homeland Security guidance then let officers quickly remove those migrants without hearing their asylum claims, CBS reported.

The lower courts: Thirteen people who say they fled persecution and three immigrant-aid groups, represented by the ACLU, sued in February 2025. In July 2025, U.S. District Judge Randolph Moss ruled that neither the Constitution nor immigration law gives the president "the sweeping authority asserted in the proclamation," Fox News reported. In April, a divided D.C. Circuit panel largely agreed. Judge Justin Walker dissented in part, saying Trump can deny all asylum claims but cannot send people to countries where they would be persecuted, SCOTUSblog reported.

What the justices will decide: The court will review two questions: whether the proclamation and its guidance are lawful, and whether federal immigration law bars the class-wide order Moss issued for all migrants covered by the policy. The Washington Examiner, which is generally seen as right-leaning, described that second question as whether the district court's ruling striking the policy down was too broad. The court declined a third question on whether the class itself was properly defined, according to the court's question sheet.

The strongest case from each side: The administration points to a law letting the president bar entry of anyone he finds "detrimental to the interests of the United States," NBC reported. Its petition calls asylum "a purely discretionary benefit" and says the appeals court "elevates empty procedures over substance" by insisting on "futile asylum applications," Roll Call reported. The Daily Signal, also generally seen as right-leaning, said the administration argues it can deny asylum to people covered by the order and does not have to accept applications likely to be rejected. The challengers say federal law lets noncitizens apply for asylum no matter how they arrived, and that the president "may not invent by fiat a new removal system that eviscerates the protections Congress mandated by statute," SCOTUSblog and NBC reported.

The numbers in dispute: The administration told the court the order has cut border encounters by 93%, Courthouse News reported. The challengers counter that by January 2025, before the order took effect, border apprehensions were already "down over 90 percent from their peak," SCOTUSblog reported. US Brief has not checked either figure against Border Patrol data.

Reaction: "The single most important factor in the president's success at the border has been this executive order," DHS general counsel James Percival wrote, adding that the department looks forward to arguing it, Courthouse News reported. The ACLU's Lee Gelernt said "the president does not have the right to unilaterally override the protections Congress has afforded those fleeing danger."

What's still unknown: As of Saturday morning, the court had not set an argument date. Arguments are expected early next year, with a decision due by the end of June or early July, according to Courthouse News and CBS. Also unknown is whether the justices will treat the asylum bar and the removal protections separately, as Walker's partial dissent did.

Sources across the spectrum This story cites right-leaning and left-leaning outlets. Every source is listed below.

12 listed sources

References listed by US Brief; a source count is not a verification score.

Editorial sourcing notes

The 93% drop in border encounters is the administration's figure from its court filing, and the "down over 90 percent from their peak" figure is the challengers'; US Brief has not checked either against Border Patrol data. Oral argument has not been scheduled. Photos are file images, not from Friday. Checked Saturday morning, Nov. 14: the court had still not set an argument date, and no new order was posted. Right-leaning coverage of Friday's cert grant, which was not found when the draft was first written, is now included from the Washington Examiner and The Daily Signal. Fox News is still used for the July 2025 district-court ruling; no Fox or New York Post write-up of Friday's grant was found.

Like US Brief? You can support it with a tip.