USBrief

We don’t bury the lede.

Back to Politics briefing Politics

Midterms in 16 days: Democrats lead House, GOP defends five Senate toss-ups

Forecasters see the House as likely to flip to Democrats on Nov. 3, while Senate control hinges on five Republican-held toss-ups. Inflation at 3.7% and gas prices up 34% in a year are weighing on Republicans, who still hold the edge on border security and crime.

By US Brief desk · Updated 2026-10-18T05:10:00-07:00

AI-assisted · US Brief desk · Sources listed below

West front of the U.S. Capitol in Washington under a clear sky

What happened

Where things stand: With 16 days until the Nov. 3 midterms, the House looks likely to change hands. Sabato's Crystal Ball rates 214 seats at least leaning Democratic, 201 at least leaning Republican and 20 as toss-ups; 218 wins a majority. The Senate is closer. Republicans hold 53 seats, so Democrats need a net gain of four. Sabato rates five races as toss-ups, all in Republican-held seats: Kansas, Iowa, Maine, Ohio and Texas. Republicans need four of the five to keep control; Democrats need two.

The polls: A Fox News poll taken Oct. 9-12 found voters backing Democrats for the House 54% to 45%, a lead that narrowed to 52% to 46% among voters certain to vote. President Trump's approval was 36%, his lowest in any Fox News survey. Just 22% approved of his handling of inflation. "Republicans have time to close these apparent gaps, but it's getting late," said Republican pollster Daron Shaw, who co-runs the survey.

The issues: Inflation rose to 3.7% in September, and gasoline was up 34.2% from a year earlier, government data released Oct. 14 showed, as reported by CNBC. Six in 10 voters in the Fox poll named the cost of living as their top economic worry, and voters trusted Democrats more on inflation by 16 points. Republicans kept the edge on crime (by 10 points) and border security (by 8), and border security was the only issue where Trump's rating was even, at 50-50. That border edge is down from 21 points four years ago.

Why it matters

A Democratic House would control spending bills and committee investigations for Trump's final two years. The Senate decides whether his judicial and executive nominees are confirmed, which is why the five toss-ups matter more to the White House than the size of any House swing.

More context

Weak spots on both sides: Democrats lead on 10 of 13 issues in the Fox poll, but only 35% of voters said the party has a clear plan for the country's problems, and its favorability is underwater by 16 points. Republicans fare slightly worse: 33% see a clear GOP plan, and the party is underwater by 23.

Races to watch (Senate): Maine — Sen. Susan Collins (R) vs. Troy Jackson (D). Suffolk (Oct. 8-11) and Rasmussen (Oct. 5-8) both had Jackson up 49% to 47%, within the margin of error. Collins led among independents in the Suffolk poll, and 12% of voters who disapprove of Trump said they back her. Iowa — Ashley Hinson (R) vs. Josh Turek (D). The NYT/Siena poll had the Republican up 1 point, a statistical tie. Ohio — Sen. Jon Husted (R) vs. Sherrod Brown (D). NYT/Siena had Brown up 3, within the margin.

More races to watch: Texas — Ken Paxton (R) vs. James Talarico (D). NYT/Siena had Talarico up 6, the clearest Democratic lead in a toss-up. Kansas — Sen. Roger Marshall (R) vs. Adam Hamilton (D). NYT/Siena had it tied, and a Libertarian on the ballot means the winner may not need a majority. Michigan, an open Democratic-held seat — Mike Rogers (R) vs. Abdul El-Sayed (D). Sabato gives Democrats a small edge, and a Fox News poll found voters split. Minnesota, also Democratic-held — Peggy Flanagan (D) led Michele Tafoya (R) 47% to 43% in a Mason-Dixon poll, a narrow lead in a state Republicans last won for Senate in 2002, Sabato noted.

What each side needs: Republicans need to hold four of the five toss-ups, four of which are in states Trump carried by double digits, despite his low approval now. Their best case is that polls are missing some GOP voters, as Sabato says pollsters may have trouble reaching certain Republicans. Democrats need two toss-ups plus holds in Michigan, Minnesota and New Hampshire. Their task is turning a lead on issues into votes for a party many of its own voters view unfavorably: 31% of Democratic House voters in the Fox poll dislike the party.

The early vote: More than 9 million mail and early in-person ballots had been cast by Oct. 18, NBC News' tracker shows, 51% from registered Democrats and 32% from registered Republicans. That gap says less than it seems. The Fox poll found mail voters favor Democrats by 33 points while in-person voters split evenly, so Democrats are expected to lead early and Republicans to make up ground on Election Day. Sabato warns that early-vote readings need "a full spoonful" of salt. The same caution applies to the GOP argument that polls undercount Republicans: Sabato says weak GOP response could just as easily reflect real defections and lower turnout.

How outlets framed it: Fox News led its poll story with Trump's record-low approval and the cost of living. The Washington Examiner described Senate Republicans as "playing defense," while National Review reported key Senate races tightening as the battlefield widens. Sabato wrote there are "not really any clear signs of a Republican recovery" but said the Senate map still gives the GOP "clear avenues" to hold on.

What would change the story: The Federal Reserve meets Oct. 27-28, and futures traders put the odds of a rate hike at about 54% after the September inflation report, CNBC reported. Another jump in gas prices, a shift in the Iran war or new state polls in Iowa and Kansas could move the toss-ups in either direction.

Sources across the spectrum This story cites right-leaning and left-leaning outlets. Every source is listed below.

10 listed sources

References listed by US Brief; a source count is not a verification score.

Editorial sourcing notes

Poll figures are each pollster's own results for the dates shown and carry margins of error of roughly 2 to 5 points; races within that range are statistical ties. Early-vote party shares reflect voter registration, not how ballots were cast. Ratings are from Sabato's Crystal Ball as of Oct. 14.

Like US Brief? You can support it with a tip.