USBrief

We don’t bury the lede.

Back to Politics briefing Politics

Both Sides: Is the economy booming, or squeezing voters?

Growth is strong and unemployment is low, but prices are up and most voters feel worse off. Here is the best case from each side as Americans vote, with the weak spot in each.

By US Brief desk · Updated 2026-11-03T13:41:00-08:00

AI-assisted · US Brief desk · Sources listed below

A lit 7-Eleven gas station sign showing regular unleaded at $4.99 and diesel at $6.89

What happened

Voters head to the polls with two very different readings of the same economy. By the big numbers, growth is strong: the economy grew at a 3.4% annual rate last quarter and unemployment was 4.2% in September, Reuters reports. By the numbers people feel, it is a squeeze: consumer prices were up 3.7% from a year earlier in September and gasoline was up 34.2%, Fox Business reports.

The scorecard both sides are arguing over, per Reuters: unemployment has stayed at or below 4.5% for five years, and weekly jobless claims are near a 57-year low. Business investment rose 12.7%. But consumer prices and average hourly earnings have each risen about 5.5% since January 2025, so typical pay has roughly kept pace with prices rather than pulling ahead. The Federal Reserve raised interest rates in September, and 30-year mortgage rates are above 7%.

The strongest case that the economy is booming: In a Fox Business column, Larry Kudlow points to 3.4% real growth, consumer spending rising at about a 4% annual rate over the last six months, about 1 million private-sector jobs added since the inauguration while federal jobs fell by 328,000, and jobless claims below 200,000. He cites Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins saying egg prices are down 54%, butter 19% and milk 5%. "If things are so bad, why are they so good?" Kudlow writes. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told CNBC, "Consumer surveys can be a little gloomy, but the consumer behavior is quite strong," according to Reuters.

Why it matters

In a Fox News poll taken Oct. 9-12, six in 10 voters named the cost of living as their top concern, 74% rated the economy negatively and just 18% said their family was better off than two years ago, according to Fox Business. How voters weigh those two pictures could decide close races today.

More context

Weak spot: The grocery items Kudlow lists are selected ones. Overall inflation was 3.7% in September, up from 2.4% in January 2026, and gasoline was up 34.2% from a year earlier, Fox Business reports. In the same Fox News poll, just 18% of voters said their family was better off than two years ago.

The strongest case that voters are being squeezed: CNN's analysis says voters are "furious" about the cost of living, driven primarily by the Iran war and also by tariffs. Gas prices rose 9.1% in September alone and fuel oil 15.3%, and Moody's estimates the Iran war is costing the average household $2,000, CNN reports. "The tariffs are definitely making much of what we consume much more expensive," Wharton's Olivia Mitchell told Fox Business. Ben Lieberman of the Competitive Enterprise Institute told Fox Business that past inflation does not reverse: "Prices don't go back to where they were, it's like a new plateau."

Weak spot: Pay has kept up. Reuters reports that wages and prices have both risen about 5.5% since January 2025, which means purchasing power is roughly flat, not falling. And the biggest single driver of the recent jump was energy tied to the Iran war, not tariffs alone: "Had it not been for the Iran war, I think the perception would be a lot better because gasoline prices would be lower," Lieberman told Fox Business.

What is still unknown: whether gas prices keep falling if U.S.-Iran talks hold, how much of the tariff cost is still working through store shelves, and whether the Fed raises rates again.

Bottom line: Both sides are citing real numbers. The strong-economy case rests on growth and jobs; the squeeze case rests on prices, especially gasoline. Voters are deciding which one they feel.

Sources across the spectrum This story cites right-leaning and left-leaning outlets. Every source is listed below.

4 listed sources

References listed by US Brief; a source count is not a verification score.

Editorial sourcing notes

Sourcing: Reuters (via Investing.com) for jobs, growth, wage and price data and the Treasury secretary's comments; Fox Business for the Fox News poll, September inflation figures and economist comments, and Larry Kudlow's column for the administration's case; CNN for the energy-price breakdown and the Moody's estimate. Poll figures are from a Fox News survey taken Oct. 9-12. The hero photo shows prices at one Oregon station on Sept. 26, 2026, not a national average.

Like US Brief? You can support it with a tip.